What are the Differences between Japanese Knives and Western Knives?
| Mini guides to kitchen knives: Kinds of kitchen knives | Materials and construction | Storing | Sharpening | Maintaining sharpness | Rust removal | Disposal | Knife skills | Western or Japanese knives | Main kitchen knife guide |
Knives are made from around the world, but Japanese knives and Western knives stand out as two distinctive styles.
They both have a rich diversity of knife-making traditions that have captured the admiration of chefs and cooking enthusiasts alike.
From design and materials to craftsmanship, traditions reflect, but distinct features define the differences that cater to specific culinary needs.
Professional chefs might seek precision and we know that many home cooks equally appreciate the art of cooking. It is important to understand the characteristics that distinguish Japanese and western knives and add a layer of appreciation to the tools we use in the kitchen.
Therefore, we’ll look at what are the differences between Japanese knives and Western knives and how they are used in the kitchen.
What is a Western or German knife?
Knives made following European and North American traditions are usually called western style knives. Because most of the high-end brands are of German origin these are often referred to as German style knives.
Western chef’s knives are usually heavier because of a thicker blade with a broader curve to provide stability which make them ideal for rough chopping, dicing, and cutting harder ingredients. The handles are often full-tang meaning the metal of the blade extends through the handle.
Wusthof and Zwilling J. A. Henckels are both German brands and are two of the best-known western knife-makers. Some of the Western knives you should have in your kitchen are:
- A chef’s knife which is indispensable in every kitchen. It is the most versatile cutting tool to handle any cutting, slicing or chopping task. Choose a knife that becomes an extension of your hand, allowing you to work with ease and precision.
- A paring knife is perfect for more delicate tasks as its small, narrow blade and pointed tip make peeling and trimming easier.
- A bread knife is the only knife that makes cutting through a crusty exterior easy without squishing the soft interior. The serrated blade of this knife ‘saws’ effortlessly through bread, cakes and other ingredients with a hard crust ensuring clean slices and preserving the texture.
What is a Japanese knife?
Japanese style knives are made following Japanese traditions and techniques. They are known for their sharpness and precision and are made of lighter materials. The straight blades are thinner and the knives serve specific purposes.
A Japanese knife doesn’t have the same curve as a western style knife which makes a rocking motion almost impossible and dicing or chopping is not recommended. However, filleting, slicing and delicate cutting are perfectly executed with such knives.
The blade is usually thinner which requires more care and because it may chip or dull faster it will probably need faster sharpening. Some of the common Japanese knives include:
- A Gyuto knife is the Japanese equivalent of a Western chef’s knife because it is most suitable for a wider range of cutting tasks. Some find it a perfect combination of knives, having the precision of a Japanese knife and the versatility of a Western knife.
- A Santoku knife is shorter with a wider blade and a flatter edge. This multi-purpose knife can handle meat, fish, and vegetables. Hence, the name santoku which translates to ‘three virtues’.
- A Nakiri knife or vegetable knife has a straight edged blade and squared-off tip making it perfect for precision cutting, slicing and chopping of vegetables.
- A Deba knife should be part of your knife arsenal if you are a seafood lover. This heavier knife is sturdy and designed for filleting and processing fish.
- A Yanagiba knife is long and thin and particularly designed to slice fish for sashimi and sushi. As with the other knives, it takes practice but the result is just perfect!
12 Points explaining a Western knife vs a Japanese knife
Indeed, the choice between a Western knife vs a Japanese knife is significant, reflecting varying philosophies in kitchen craftsmanship. This brief comparison explores the differences and strengths of each type of knife.
1. Blade Material
Western knives are made from softer steel, whilst Japanese knives use harder steel.2. Edge Angle
A Western knife usually has a 20-22 degree bevel, compared to the sharper 15 degree or less bevel of a Japanese knife.3. Blade Shape
Western knives feature a curved blade for rocking cuts, whereas Japanese knives have straighter blades for precise slicing.4. Weight and Balance
Western knives are generally heavier and balanced towards the handle. Japanese knives tend to be lighter with a balance closer to the blade.5. Handle Design
A Western knife often has synthetic or reinforced wood handles, whilst a Japanese knife features cylindrical or D-shaped wooden handles.6. Versatility
Western knives are designed for a range of tasks. On the other had, Japanese knives are more specialized.7. Maintenance and Care
Western knives are more durable and often dishwasher safe, in contrast to Japanese knives which require more careful maintenance.8. Price Range
Western knives come in a wide range of prices. Japanese knives, however, particularly premium artisan-made models, tend to be more expensive.9. Aesthetic and Craftsmanship
A Western knife focuses on functionality, whereas a Japanese knife is known for their serious craftsmanship and aesthetic appeal.10. Sharpening and Honing
Sharpening Western knives is relatively easier; Japanese knives require more skillful sharpening with a whetstone.11. Edge Retention
Western knives may need more frequent sharpening, but Japanese knives hold their edge longer. It should also be noted that they are more challenging to sharpen when dull.12. Types of Knives
Western kitchens typically use a few versatile knives, as opposed to the more varied and specialized knives found in Japanese kitchens.In reality, the discussion of Western knife vs Japanese knife boils down to personal preference and specific culinary requirements. Western knives offer durability and versatility, making them suitable for a variety of kitchen tasks.
Japanese knives, known for their precision and craftsmanship, cater to more specialized culinary techniques. Both styles have their unique advantages, and the choice ultimately depends on the user’s cooking style and what they value most in a kitchen tool.
What type of knife do you really need?
Some swear by western knives and others prefer to work with Japanese knives, but if you have the budget, we recommend having both depending on how often you cook and the dishes you prepare.
We have both and use them for different purposes. The western chef knife is perfect for chopping and cutting through hard ingredients, whilst we use the Japanese knife for filleting and slicing fish.
We recommend starting with a Western-style knife and once you feel comfortable, and are ready to cook dishes that need more precise cutting and slicing, a Japanese knife can be a wise buy.
Regardless of what type of kitchen knife you choose, if you want to learn all about knives, a good place to start is our comprehensive guide to kitchen knives.